Giuseppe Verdi: Falstaff – Best recordings

Falstaff is an opera it took me a little time to get into, even though it is considered one of Verdi’s greatest achievements. Now, I appreciate it a lot: the blend of comedy and biting irony about human nature is admirably set to music by Verdi, who showed here that even in his later years, he was still able to renew his art.

If you want to get into it, I think it’s important to understand that this is not a traditional opera with choruses and arias in short, self-contained pieces of music, as you might find in Rigoletto. It’s closer to a stage play, where the music underlines the action on stage rather than structuring it. You have a quick succession of scenes flowing seamlessly into one another. In this way, it is different from Tristan und Isolde, which is constructed more or less as one continuous whole.

The central figure here is, of course, Falstaff—a mix of a pompous nobleman, impoverished, living well beyond his means, and ultimately just interested in enjoying a good life. Perhaps closer to our modern way of life? Ford is, in a way, no better, wanting everything to go according to his rules and thus dictating how everyone else should live. In the end, however, it is the women who pull the strings of the plot from beginning to end. Verdi, with the help of his librettist Boito, created a great synthesis of Shakespeare’s original plays. You can easily imagine the fun he had while composing every second of this music, from the biting irony of certain scenes to the subtle philosophical reflections woven throughout.

What should one single out in particular? The ensembles are great, especially of course the closing fugue, “Tutto nel mondo è burla”, which is a blend of deep philosophical thought, truly learned music, and pure fun. But, in my view, it’s to reducing to get out some excerpts…

Which recording should you get? For me, the classic historical recordings—Toscanini, of course, as well as Rossi in some live performances or on Italian radio—remain the very best, even with their archival sound. Why? Because Taddei and Gobbi are probably by far the finest Falstaffs of the modern era, blending the comic element with truly great singing. Karajan’s 1956 recording with Gobbi and modern sound is also great, though perhaps lacking a touch of italianità. For a more recent recording, I would go with Abbado’s.

RecordingArtistsWhat I likeWhat I don’t likeSo/SoQuality
Herbert von Karajan (1956)Falstaff: Tito Gobbi
Alice: Elisabeth Schwarzkopf
Meg: Nan Merriman
Mrs. Quickly: Fedora Barbieri
Ford: Rolando Panerai
A lot of details may be heard in the orchestra
The playing is very lively
Gobbi is one of the best Falstaffs of the post WW2 time
The other singers are excellent in there roles (especially Panerai)
The sound balance is very strongly in favor of the orchestra
Barbieris sound is not the most beautiful
Schwarzkopf has a little tendency to overintellectualism
***** (good early stereo)
Herbert von Karajan (1980)Falstaff: Giuseppe Taddei
Alice: Raina Kabaivanska
Meg: Trudeliese Schmidt
Mrs. Quickly: Christa Ludwig
Ford: Rolando Panerai
You may hear a lot of orchestral details you won’t hear in other recordings
The orchestral playing is astonishing
It lacks some spontaneity and vitalityThe singers are all very good, but nothing is outstanding*** (early digital)
sir George Solti (1993)Falstaff: José van Dam
Alice: Luciana Serra
Meg: Susan Graham
Mrs. Quickly: Marjana Lipovšek
Ford: Paolo Coni
Van Dam is quite good here
Solti energetic conducting
The BPO is a little disappointing in comparison to what should be possible with such an orchestraThe singers are all very good, but none is outstanding**** (good live digital)
Claudio Abbado (2001)Falstaff: Bryan Terfel
Alice: Adrianne Pieczonka
Meg: Stella Doufexis
Mrs. Quickly: Larissa Diadkova
Ford: Thomas Hampson
Very equilibrated
Abbado is conducting a good mixture between liveliness and transparency
The BPO is a little disappointing in comparison to what should be possible with such an orchestraTerfel sings and plays the role well, but he lacks italianità
The other singers are all very good, no one is outstanding
**** (good digital)